Skip to content

 Our Showroom will be CLOSED early 11/25 and ALL DAY 11/26 for Thanksgiving!

New customers 10% off with WELCOME10.

Flat rate shipping on all indoor furniture

20% OFF Bedroom, Dining, and Bookcases!

It's Black Friday ALL MONTH LONG!

The Stain & Finish Guide

Wood stain colors for furniture get picked from a photograph, which is the one thing that cannot show you how a finish will land. There are 117 of them here, spread across 14 woods. This page covers how to narrow that down to two or three, and why the same color is effectively a different finish on a different board.

How Many Finishes Are There?

A hundred and seventeen named finishes, held as 559 physical chips. The standard stain range runs to 77 colors, the specialty range adds 40 more, and there are 55 leather colors on top for upholstered pieces.

The chip count is higher than the color count because every stain is cut across a spread of timbers. Which is why a color name by itself settles almost nothing, and why the ranges are cut this way in the first place.
Guide table
Range Colors Chips
Standard stains 77 438
Specialty stains 40 66
Leather 55 55

Every one of these is a physical piece of finished timber or hide. We do not sell liquid stain, and nothing here is a printed swatch.

Where Do You Start Looking?

Three ranges, and which one you want depends on what the piece is. Stained hardwood for almost everything, the specialty range when you want paint or a weathered surface, and leather when the piece has a seat.

Nothing stops you ordering from more than one. Most people comparing a painted base against a stained top end up with chips from two of the three.

Three Samples Come Back Off Your Order

Chips are $12 each. Up to three are credited against your purchase, and if you order more than three, the rest are refunded once they come back to the store.

Why Does One Color Change by Wood?

Because the timber underneath is doing half the work. Where the pores are wide, the pigment sinks into them and the figure comes up darker than everything around it. Where the grain is tight, the color stays level across the whole face.

It also explains why some woods carry 60 options and others carry 17. Timber that already has a strong tone leaves fewer finishes that genuinely add anything, so those ranges stay short rather than padded.
Guide table
Species Standard stains offered
Oak 60
Brown maple 50
Rough sawn brown maple 48
Quartersawn white oak 48
Hard maple 48
Hickory 46
Cherry 38
Plain sawn white oak 22
Walnut 19
Sap cherry 17
Wormy maple 14
Elm 12

Fourteen Colors Work Across Nearly Everything

Fourteen finishes are cut on ten species or more, which makes them the practical choice if a room has to hold pieces in different woods.

Seashell appears on twelve, and Bel Air, Natural, Sealy, Harvest and Tavern each appear on eleven. Natural Effect, Wicker, Golden Pecan, Almond, Carbon, Asbury Brown, Lite Asbury and Michael's Cherry are each on ten.

The limit is that wide availability is not a recommendation. These are the colors most likely to exist on the species you need, which is a different question from whether they suit your room.

Depth Narrows the Gap Between Species

Push the color deep enough and the differences between timbers begin to collapse. Two boards that look nothing alike unfinished can arrive looking like relatives once a near-black stain is on them.

There is a budget consequence in that. A piece headed for the darkest end of the range is a piece where paying for a premium species buys you less than it would in a pale finish.

The limit is texture. Pigment colors the pore structure; it does not fill it, so an open-grained board announces itself at close range whatever shade sits on top.

Which Finish Family Are You In?

Seventy-seven standard colors sort into four groups, and almost everybody belongs in one of them before they start. Working out which saves you scrolling past sixty chips that were never candidates.

They run from the finishes that let the timber speak to the ones that largely replace it.
Natural Effect-Quartersawn White Oak-Samples-The Amish House

Clear and Natural

Finishes that seal the wood and change its color as little as possible. Natural, Natural Effect and Seashell sit here, on ten to twelve species each.

They suit figured species, where the grain is the reason you chose the wood. On quartersawn white oak or hickory a clear finish is the only one that shows you what you actually bought.

The limit is that nothing is hidden. Color variation between boards, sapwood and any mineral streaking all stay fully visible.
Golden Pecan-Oak

Light and Warm

The honey, wheat and pale amber end. Golden Pecan, Harvest, Honey, Almond, Wicker, Granola, Sand and Bamboo live in this group.

These are the finishes that keep a room bright and make a space feel larger, which is why they suit smaller rooms and north-facing ones. They read as traditional without reading as formal.

The limit is that they show marks sooner. A light finish gives a scratch more contrast to work with than a mid brown does.
Michael's Cherry-Brown Maple

Mid Browns

The largest group and the default for most dining rooms. Michael's Cherry, Asbury Brown, Chestnut, Medium Walnut, Provincial, Briar and Tavern sit in here.

They are the finishes that look like furniture, in the sense that most people's mental picture of a wooden table is somewhere in this band. They also hide daily wear better than anything lighter.

The limit is sameness. It is the band where the most pieces end up, so a mid brown room needs its interest from form rather than color.
Onyx-Oak

Dark and Near Black

Ebony, Onyx, Carbon, India Ink, Charwood and Dark Knight anchor this end.

A dark finish gives a room weight and makes a single piece read as deliberate against pale walls. On a close-grained species it comes up almost solid.

The limit is dust and light. Dark surfaces show every particle and every fingerprint, and in a dim room a dark piece can disappear into the wall behind it.

Tell Us What It Has to Sit Beside

Photograph the floor, the cabinets or whatever you are keeping, name the timber you are leaning toward, and expect a shortlist of the chips worth ordering.

What Are the Specialty Finishes?

Forty finishes that do something other than color the wood. Paint, distressing, weathering and burnishing each change the surface rather than just its tone, and they sit in a separate range because they are produced differently.

This is where to look if a stain was never going to get you there. A painted base under a stained top is a common pairing and it needs chips from two ranges.
Chelsea Grey-Brown Maple-Samples-The Amish House

Painted and Opaque

Solid color that covers the grain instead of coloring it. Bright White, Country White, Black, Chalk, Accessible Beige, Chelsea Grey and Oatmilk sit here.

Paint suits kitchen and dining pieces meant to answer to cabinetry rather than to other furniture, and it is the standard route for a two-tone build. Most of the painted range is cut on brown maple.

The limit is repair. A chip in a painted surface is more visible and less forgiving than a scratch in a stained one.
Distressed Weathered Burlap-Oak-Samples-The Amish House

Distressed and Weathered

Finishes that simulate age, with the Distressed Weathered group running through Burlap, Hazelnut, Rockledge, Savanna, Tortilla, Asphalt, Iron, Smog and Treebark.

They suit farmhouse and rustic rooms, and they pair naturally with rough sawn surfaces and rustic grades. The character is applied rather than earned, which is the honest way to describe it.

The limit is commitment. A distressed finish is a strong stylistic statement and it is not something that can be undone later without refinishing.
Tavern Burnished-Quartersawn White Oak-Samples-The Amish House

Burnished

A finish worked back at the edges and corners so the color is softer where a piece would naturally wear. Almond Burnished, Tavern Burnished and Michael's Cherry Burnished are the examples.

It is a quieter version of distressing, and it suits traditional rooms where you want warmth without the piece looking deliberately aged.

The limit is subtlety. The effect is genuinely hard to see in a photograph, so this is a group to order as chips rather than judge from a screen.
Weathered Greystone-Brown Maple-Samples-The Amish House

Weathered Whites and Greys

Weathered Beige, Weathered Greystone, Weathered Snow White, Weathered Tusk and Weathered Greek Villa. The Muted range sits with the standard stains rather than here.

These are the coastal and farmhouse finishes, pale and slightly chalky, and they keep a large piece from dominating a light room.

The limit is species. Pale and opaque finishes are cut on a narrower set of woods, so check the combination before planning around one.

How Do You Narrow 117 Down to Three?

Pick a starting point and let it eliminate. Four of them work, and which you use depends on what in the room is already fixed and cannot change.

Three chips is the number to aim for, since that is what gets credited against an order and it is also about as many as anyone can usefully compare at once.
Golden Pecan-Walnut

Start From the Wood

If the species is settled, the species has already cut the list for you.

Walnut offers 19 standard colors and sap cherry 17, which is a shortlist before you have decided anything. Oak offers 60, so this route helps least if oak is where you landed.

The limit is sequence. This only works if the species decision genuinely comes first, which it should when the grain matters to you.

Start From What Will Not Change

Floors, trim, brick and cabinet doors outlast most furniture, so they make better reference points than anything you could replace.

Choose one of them to answer to and ignore the rest. A finish that tries to agree with the floor and the trim and the countertop usually agrees with none of them.

The limit is the near miss. Landing one shade away from a fixed surface looks like a failed match, where an obvious difference reads as intentional.

Start From Light or Dark

Deciding the band before the color removes three quarters of the range in one move.

Light finishes open a room and show wear sooner. Dark finishes add weight and show dust. Mid browns do neither strongly, which is why so much furniture ends up there.

The limit is that the room decides this more than taste does. A dark piece in a dim north-facing room is a different object from the same piece in full light.

Start From What You Already Own

Anything you intend to keep writes the brief for everything you add.

Bring timber into the conversation alongside color, since a sideboard in one species is far simpler to sit beside in that same species than in another. Age complicates it further, because an older piece has moved on from the tone it left the workshop with.

The limit is what is achievable. Ask us how close a match is realistic before you commit to chasing one, because the answer is sometimes that contrast will serve you better.

Where Do You Want to Browse?

Six ways into the ranges, depending on whether you are starting from a wood, a color or a piece. The first two are the same 438 chips sorted differently.

Use the stain-color view if you have a shade in mind and the species view if you already know the timber.
By Species

By Species

All 438 standard chips grouped by wood, with a description of each species.
Leather

Leather

55 Heartland leather colors for upholstered seating.

How Do the Samples Actually Work?

Order the chips, they arrive within 48 business hours, and up to three come back off your order when you buy. Anything beyond three is refunded once the extras are returned to the store, which keeps the cost down for everyone and keeps the chips in circulation.

The important part is the order of events. A furniture order can go in first and the timber or finish can still move afterward, which is what takes the risk out of it.
Harvest-Cherry

What Turns Up

A physical piece of the species you chose, finished in the stain you chose. Not a printed card and not a liquid sample.

It is worth saying plainly because the search term brings people looking for a tin. We finish furniture rather than sell the materials, so there is no liquid stain to buy here.

The limit is scale. Chips are small, and the same finish spread across a six foot top will always land heavier than the sample led you to expect.

Where to Put It

Carry it into the room the furniture is destined for, and set it beside whatever it will have to live with.

A finish that reads warm under a bedside lamp can turn flat under a ceiling fitting, so give the chip a few days in that room rather than ruling on it the moment you open the envelope.

The limit is background. Lay the chip on the floor or hold it to the cabinet door you care about, since a pale countertop makes almost any finish look good.

You Have Ten Days to Change Your Mind

Timber and finish both stay open for ten days after you place the order, at no cost. Moving to a costlier timber adjusts the total, but the change itself is never billed.

The window exists precisely so the chips can land while the order is still open, which is what makes placing both together sensible rather than reckless.

The limit is the clock. Those ten days are counted from the order date, not from delivery of the chips, so open the envelope the day it arrives.
ORDER STAIN SAMPLES

Finishing a Kitchen at the Same Time?

Cabinetry is finished on its own range rather than this one, so a near-match across the two is harder than a deliberate difference. Our sister company works in the same hardwoods and can quote the fitted side.

What Should You Know Before Ordering?

Your finish adds nothing to the invoice. Across all 117, the number is driven by which timber you chose and how big the piece is, never by the color sitting on top.

That is worth stating because it removes the only reason to compromise. There is no cheaper stain and no premium stain, so choose the one you want.

The Terms

Guide table
Cost of the finish Nothing. Every stain and paint in the range is included
Samples $12 each. Up to three credited against your order
Extra samples Refunded once returned to the store
Despatch Within 48 business hours of ordering
Changing your mind Timber and finish both stay open for ten days after ordering, at no cost
What we do not sell Liquid stain. Every sample is finished timber or leather

Order chips for everything you are seriously weighing, including a second species. The cost is recoverable and the decision is not.

Get It Down to Three, Then Order Them

Settle the species first if the grain matters to you, pick the band before the color, and let whatever is fixed in the room do the eliminating. When three are left, order all three, because three is what comes back off the invoice.

If you would rather not guess, call us at 615-819-2772, describe what you are matching, and we will shortlist the finishes worth your time.

The sample ranges are there to work through in your own time, and the chips can be held against our floor models at the showroom on Nolensville Road. We are open Tuesday through Saturday, 10 am to 5 pm.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. Everything in the samples range is a finished piece of timber or leather, cut and coated so you can see the result rather than mix it. We finish furniture rather than supply the materials for it.
Standard chips are $12 each. Up to three are credited against your order when you buy. If you order more than three, we refund the extras once they are returned to the store.
No. Every finish in the range is included in the price. Timber and dimensions set the number, so there is nothing to gain by settling for a color you like less.
Yes. The specialty range covers painted and opaque finishes including Bright White, Country White, Black and Chelsea Grey, most often applied to brown maple. Order those chips from the specialty collection rather than the main one.
Because not every finish improves every timber. Woods with strong natural color carry fewer options, which is why walnut offers 19 standard stains and oak offers 60. Tell us the pairing you want and we will confirm whether it can be done.
Often closely, though an exact hit is rare, and landing one shade off tends to look worse than an obvious difference. Photograph the floor, name the timber you have in mind, and expect a straight answer on what is achievable.
Finishes that simulate age, applied rather than earned. The distressed weathered group covers tones from Burlap and Hazelnut through to Asphalt and Iron, and they suit farmhouse rooms and rough sawn surfaces.
They leave us within 48 business hours of the order. A furniture order then stays open for ten days on both timber and finish, which is why most people place the two together.