Why Oak Sits at the Bottom
Oak grows widely across the eastern United States, mills predictably and arrives at a workshop in consistent widths. Abundance and predictability both show up in the price.
None of that makes it a lesser wood. Oak is hard, it wears extremely well, and its grain is the reason a great deal of American furniture looks the way it does.
The limit is the grain itself. It is assertive, it repeats, and on a large flat surface some people find it busy rather than beautiful.
Why Quartersawn Oak Sits at the Top
Quartersawing cuts the log radially instead of straight through, which exposes the medullary rays as pale flecks running across the board.
That cut yields far fewer usable boards from the same tree, and the waste is the cost. What you buy is a figure no other species produces and a board that moves less with the seasons than plain sawn stock.
The limit is budget and taste. It is the most expensive choice on nearly every piece, and the fleck is distinctive enough that you either want it or you do not.
What the Difference Buys You on a Full Set
On one chair, that gap is modest. Multiply it by six and it becomes a bench, or most of a buffet.
Work the species decision out across everything you intend to order rather than on the first piece. The spread compounds, and it compounds hardest on dining rooms, where you buy the same item six times.
The limit is false economy. Dropping to a species you do not like to save the price of a bench gets you a dining room you look at every day and never quite settle on.